Shelbyville, IL Real Estate

Home › Neighborhoods › Shelbyville, IL

Shelbyville, IL Real Estate

Shelbyville sits on the Kaskaskia River next to 11,100-acre Lake Shelbyville. Here’s the real Shelby County market, and the corridor team that covers it.

Shelby County Courthouse (1880) with Civil War soldiers' monument on the public square
Photo: Matt Turner (MT_Image) / Flickr, via Wikimedia Commons · CC BY 2.0
$157,000
Median sale price
▲ 7.5% YoY
8 days
Median days on market
21
Active listings now
86
Homes sold, 12 mo

Shelbyville, Illinois — housing market at a glance

Median sale price
$157,000
Days on market
8 days
Homes sold (12 mo.)
86
Active listings
21

Source: MARIS trailing-12-month closed residential sales. Updated monthly.

The Shelbyville market right now

Shelbyville closed 86 homes over the past 12 months at a median of $157,000 — up 7.5% from the prior 12-month period. Homes reach contract in a median of 8 days. With 86 closings behind these numbers, this is a directional read, not a precision instrument.

12-month price trend

▲ 7.5% year over year
Prior 12 months
$146,000
Past 12 months
$157,000

Figures reflect trailing-12-month closed residential sales in Shelbyville, IL (Shelby County) across the MARIS, RMLS, MRED and CIBR feeds, deduped for border-area double-listings. With 86 sales in the sample, individual transactions still move the numbers — lean on a specialist who knows the individual streets.

If you’re selling

With 21 homes actively listed against 86 sales in the past year, inventory here is exceptionally tight. A 8-day median time-to-contract means a well-priced, well-presented home won’t sit long — if anything, the challenge is finding sellers, not buyers.

If you’re buying

At a $157,000 median, Shelbyville is one of the corridor’s most affordable markets — but with 21 homes active at the moment, buyers need someone watching for what’s coming, not just browsing what’s live today.

What your money buys in Shelbyville

The median home runs about 1,512 sq ft at ~$104/sq ft. Across the last 12 months of closed residential sales (MARIS):

~$100,925
Around $100,925 — smaller or older homes, common starter buys.
~$157,000
About $157,000 — the typical Shelbyville home.
~$230,000
Around $230,000 — more space or proximity to Lake Shelbyville.
$289,500+
$289,500 and up — the largest homes and lake-adjacent properties.

Homes for sale in Shelbyville

See what’s live in Shelbyville right now — or have an Artemis agent set up a custom search and surface the right home the day it lists, including coming-soon and off-market homes you won’t find on a portal.

Get the Shelbyville market report — free, monthly

What sold, what’s for sale, and where prices are heading — in your inbox once a month. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Your Effingham corridor specialists

The team covering the whole corridor.

Curtis Thompson anchors buyer-side representation across the Effingham corridor — Alicia Winskill and Harley Harris round out the team, backed by the full Artemis system: IRIS pricing, a 6,000-buyer database, and Zillow Showcase on every listing.

BEST FOR BUYERS WHO WANT EVERY DOLLAR NEGOTIATED OFF THE PRICE
Curtis Thompson
Curtis Thompson
Buyer-side negotiation specialist
$21.2K
Avg buyer-side savings, 20 closings
44 total closings
Across 3 active years

Curtis works the buyer side hard. Across 20 buyer-side closings he has averaged $21.2K in savings for his buyers, with 36 total closings on the board over three active years. He’s backed by the full Artemis team: a 6,000-buyer database, the IRIS pricing engine, and Zillow Showcase on every listing.

Talk to Curtis
BEST FOR buyers and sellers across the Effingham, Mattoon, Charleston & central-IL corridor
Alicia Winskill
Alicia Winskill
Effingham corridor producer · joined Artemis 2026
$5.9M · 38 sides
2026 production (Jan–Jul) — #2 producer in her Effingham ZIP
#19 board-wide
CIBR board ranking, central Illinois

Alicia Winskill covers the Effingham, Mattoon, and Charleston corridor with real production behind her — $5.9M and 38 sides in 2026 alone, the #2 producer in her Effingham ZIP. Backed by the full Artemis system: IRIS pricing, a 6,000-buyer database, and Zillow Showcase on every listing.

Talk to Alicia
BEST FOR buyers and sellers across the Effingham, Vandalia, Salem & Centralia corridor
Harley Harris
Harley Harris
Effingham corridor agent · since 2026
2 closings
$845K combined volume since joining the team
Effingham corridor
Coverage across Vandalia, Salem & Centralia

Harley Harris covers the greater Effingham corridor for Artemis — Vandalia, Salem, and Centralia included — backed by the full Artemis system: IRIS pricing, a 6,000-buyer database, and Zillow Showcase on every listing.

Talk to Harley

Living in Shelbyville

Shelbyville was founded in 1827 and named for Isaac Shelby, the Revolutionary War hero and first governor of Kentucky; the county seat grew up along the Kaskaskia River. The town’s best-known feature today is Lake Shelbyville, an 11,100-acre U.S. Army Corps of Engineers reservoir built between 1963 and 1970 immediately east of downtown. Shelbyville also has a genuine invention pedigree: Josephine Cochrane built and patented the first practical mechanical dishwasher in a shed behind her Shelbyville home in 1886, and in 1929–30 local inventor Raymore McDonald developed the first commercial pick-up hay baler here. The 2020 census recorded 4,674 residents.

Lake Shelbyville11,100-acre Army Corps of Engineers reservoir on the Kaskaskia River just east of town, with boat ramps, camping, and 6,000-plus acres of surrounding habitat.
Forest Park & the Chautauqua AuditoriumCity park built around Crystal Lake fishing lagoon; home to the 1903 Chautauqua Auditorium, a 20-sided wooden meeting hall on the National Register of Historic Places.
Birthplace of the dishwasherJosephine Cochrane patented the first practical mechanical dishwasher here in 1886; she was posthumously inducted into the National Inventors Hall of Fame in 2006.
HSHS Good Shepherd HospitalShelby County’s only hospital.

Drive times from Shelbyville

Typical drive times by car (Google Maps, light traffic):

~2 hr 12 min
Downtown St. Louis, MO
~35 min
Mattoon, IL · via IL-16
~45 min
Effingham, IL · via IL-32

Shelbyville is served by the Shelbyville Community Unit School District 4. For enrollment, test results and programs at each school, see the Illinois Report Card, and tour the schools to judge fit. District lines can split a town, so confirm the district for a specific address before you buy.

Neighborhoods & areas worth knowing

Downtown & the square — the historic core near the Kaskaskia River
Lake Shelbyville area — properties toward the reservoir on the east side of town
Sullivan & Mattoon — the larger markets nearby — part of our everyday coverage area

Shelbyville real estate FAQ

What’s a typical Shelbyville home price?

The median sale price over the past 12 months is $157,000 across 86 closed residential sales. Entry-level homes run below that; larger and newer homes run well above.

How fast are homes selling in Shelbyville?

The median home goes under contract in about 8 days, against only ~21 active listings — a tight, seller-leaning market.

What was invented in Shelbyville?

The mechanical dishwasher — Josephine Cochrane built her first working model in a shed behind her Shelbyville home and patented it in 1886. It won top honors at the 1893 World’s Fair in Chicago.

How big is Lake Shelbyville?

11,100 acres — a U.S. Army Corps of Engineers reservoir on the Kaskaskia River immediately east of downtown, with a 34,000-acre project area around it.

How fast do homes sell in Shelbyville?

The median home goes under contract in about 31 days, and inventory is exceptionally tight right now — the real challenge is finding the next listing, not finding a buyer for it.

Do you also cover Sullivan and Mattoon?

Yes — those are part of the same central-Illinois corridor our team covers every week, along with Effingham and the surrounding towns.

Which Artemis agent handles Shelbyville?

With Artemis, the entire team works Shelbyville consistently — it’s a market we cover every day. But you have a specific situation, and the right starting point depends on what you need. Any of our flagship agents will either be the best fit directly, or point you to the specialist that matches your goals. In Shelbyville, a few excellent starting points: Curtis Thompson if you want a buyer agent who consistently negotiates real money off the price. Not sure where to start? Schedule a quick consult with team leadership — we’ll match you with the right agent for your situation.

Explore the area

Explore more of our central Illinois markets:

Two ways to start in Shelbyville

Pick your move — each one becomes a real person on the Artemis team working your deal.

Get your Property Intelligence Report

  • What your home is worth — three pricing strategies, not one guess
  • The live MLS comps behind the number + your home’s competitive position
  • The exact plan to sell for more, not just faster
  • Built by your specialist from real local sales data — back to you within a day
Request Your Report

Get VIP Buyer Access

  • First look at coming-soon & off-market homes before they hit Zillow
  • Auto-alerts the moment a new Shelbyville listing fits your search
  • A negotiator who wins bidding wars & lands seller concessions
  • The 6,000-buyer Artemis network working in your corner
Get VIP Access

Shelbyville market data: MARIS MLS residential closings, trailing 12 months, as of November 2026. Refreshed monthly. See full methodology.