The questions most agents can’t answer about their own results.
Hiring an agent decides five or six figures for your family. These are the questions that separate a measured operation from an agent running on luck. Print them. Ask every agent you interview, including us.
A sold sign in the yard proves nothing.
A sold sign tells you an agent closed a deal once. It says nothing about whether that agent was worth hiring. Most sellers interview for a job they have never had to hire for, so they ask the safe questions and learn nothing.
The safe questions sound like this: how long have you been licensed, how many homes have you sold, do you know my neighborhood, what is your commission. Every agent answers all four the same way. Years licensed only means an agent kept a license, not that the agent closed a deal last month.
The question that works is different. Show me your numbers, show me your process, show me the system you run today. A good agent welcomes that. We wrote this page because we can answer all of it on the record. (Bring it to every agent you sit with, including ours.)
Questions to ask before you hire a listing agent.
Each one is built so a real operation answers in numbers, and an agent running on vibes stalls.
“What percentage of your listings actually close?”
Listings withdraw, cancel, and expire more than sellers expect. A good answer is a specific number with a source. A bad answer is “almost all of them.”
“What does your seller premium look like against the comps?”
Closing a deal and getting top dollar are different jobs. Ask the agent to show their sale prices against the comparable baseline, with the math. We have added $4.14M in seller premium across 456 listings. A bad answer is “I always get full price.”
“What share of your listings sell above the original asking price?”
Selling over the original list takes pricing strategy and marketing velocity, not luck. Ask for the rate with a timeframe. Across our book 19.8% of listings close above original list, 118 of 596. Named agents run higher when their system runs end to end. Chad Klein lands 35.2% over-asking and completes 91.7% of what he takes.
“What do you put into marketing my listing, and who pays for it?”
Some agents bill sellers for marketing. Others build it into the listing and eat the cost. Ask for the dollars and the photography standard. We run 38 photos on the average listing against a regional norm near 21, write 1,048-character narrative descriptions, and put a Showcase 3D tour on 76% of listings, all included. A bad answer is “I do a lot of marketing.”
“How many active buyers sit in your team’s database?”
A buyer network is a marketing asset, not a vanity metric. More matched buyers means more showings and more offers. Ask for a number with segmentation. Our database holds about 6,000 buyers, sorted by price band, school district, and bedroom count, so a new listing matches a real slice on day one. A bad answer is “I keep a good list.”
“How recent are the comps you priced my home on?”
Comp quality lives or dies on recency. A comp from last year barely informs a shifting market, and stale comps inflate a listing presentation. Ask what window the agent uses. Ours pulls 90-day comps inside a tight radius, with older comps only when recent data runs thin, off a live MARIS feed. A bad answer leans on 12-month-old sales as current evidence.
“Can I see a real pre-listing report you produced for a client?”
The analytical work before a listing previews how the agent runs the listing itself. Ask to see a redacted example, valuation, comps, marketing plan, projected net. We produce a Property Intelligence Report for every seller we meet, built on our own IRIS tool. A bad answer is “I will walk you through comps in person,” meaning no document exists.
“What happens if my home does not sell?”
Most listing agreements run six months. If the strategy stalls, you want a defined next move, not a shrug. Ask for the commitment in writing. We revise the full marketing plan, reset strategy, and release you from the agreement if we turn out to be the wrong fit. A bad answer is “my listings always sell,” which is statistically impossible.
Questions to ask before you hire a buyer’s agent.
Buying is offense. The right agent wins you money and access, not a tour.
“What is your bidding-war win rate for buyers?”
In a contested market this stat decides whether you get the house. Ask for the team number and the named agents behind it. Our buyers win 45.3% of contested closings at or above original list, 422 of 931, direct from MARIS. Shannon McCready leads the team at 64.3%, and Jake Deiters runs 61.0% over his career. A bad answer is “I win most of them.”
“How often do your buyers walk away with seller money?”
Concessions cover closing costs, repairs, rate buydowns, and warranties. They are real dollars back in your pocket. Ask for the capture rate. Our buyers pull seller concessions on 36.7% of closings, against a 30% market rate, so our buyers are more likely to leave with seller money in hand. Brad Hasquin captures concessions on 52.6% of his buys.
“How much do your buyers typically save against list?”
A negotiator measures the gap between list and final price. Ask for the dollar figure with a sample size. Across 509 below-list buyer closings our average came to $19,000 under list, and we have saved buyers $8.64M total across 931 closings. Curtis Thompson averages $22,989 below list. A bad answer is “I get a good deal,” with no number.
“Do I get listings before they hit the MLS, and exactly how?”
If an agent says yes, push for the mechanism. A real coming-soon workflow needs team infrastructure a solo agent rarely has. Ask to see the process. Our VIP Buyer Access matches you against the 6,000-buyer database and previews fitting homes 3 to 7 days before MLS entry, a trickle, not a flood. A bad answer is “sometimes, if I hear about something.”
“Do I have to pay you, and how does that work now?”
The honest answer after the August 2024 NAR changes is “it depends on the deal.” Most of the time sellers still agree to cover part or all of buyer-agent compensation, and the worst case is known up front. Ask the agent to put the structure in writing before you tour. A bad answer claims representation is free as a flat fact, which is a compliance problem.
“What is your plan if my home has multiple offers?”
Agents who handle contested offers carry a framework. Agents who do not only tell you to bid more. Ask for the specifics, escalation terms, earnest money, contingency strategy, communication with the listing agent. We win without gouging, no waived inspection and no overpaying, and we capture credits on the way in. A bad answer is “we will offer more.”
Two more cut deeper than any stat. Ask each agent to walk you through a typical client week by week, and ask to call two clients who closed in the last 90 days, not the testimonial reel. A good agent answers both without flinching.
Interview warning signs.
Each one shows up in the room before it shows up in your transaction.
“I do 100 deals a year,” with no addresses
Volume is easy to claim. Ask for three to five specific closed addresses from the last six months. A real producer names them on the spot.
“All my listings sell at full price”
That outcome is statistically impossible in any normal market. The agent is either exaggerating or remembering only the top few.
The agent trashes other agents by name
Strong agents compete on their own numbers. An agent who runs down a competitor is covering for a weak offer.
No written agreement on hand
Every working agent carries current listing and buyer-representation templates. “Putting something together” means run.
The agent will not show numbers
An agent who hides close rates, concession rates, and below-list savings either does not track them or does not like them.
“Sign right now, this market is moving”
Urgency is sales pressure, not service. A real agent gives you a few days to decide and earns the yes.
Our answers, on the record.
We hand you the questions because we built a system that answers them. Every cell traces to MARIS or the live ELYSIUM scorecard.
- Seller premium: $4.14M added across 456 listings.
- Over-asking sale rate: 19.8% of listings close above original list.
- Marketing standard: 38 photos per listing, 1,048-character descriptions, Showcase on 76% of listings.
- Marketing Investment Score: 67.1 of 100, near twice the regional median.
- Buyer database: about 6,000 segmented buyers your listing matches on day one.
- Bidding-war win rate: 45.3% of contested closings at or above list (team).
- Named leaders: Shannon McCready 64.3%, Jake Deiters 61.0% lifetime.
- Concession capture: 36.7% of buyer closings, vs 30% market.
- Below-list savings: $19,000 average, $8.64M saved across 931 closings.
- Coming-soon access: VIP Buyer Access previews fits 3 to 7 days before MLS.
- Representation terms: updated for the post-NAR rules, written before you tour.
See the methodology for sample sizes, the control baseline, and the query behind each number. We also state what we will not claim, which is why what we do claim holds up.
Interviewing an agent, answered.
What are the most important questions to ask a real estate agent?
Ask the agent to show numbers, not adjectives. For a listing agent: what percentage of your listings actually close, what is your seller premium against the comps, and can I see a real pre-listing report. For a buyer’s agent: what is your bidding-war win rate, how often do your buyers get seller concessions, and how much do your buyers typically save against list. A measured operation answers each in specifics with a source. An agent running on luck stalls.
How do I know if an agent is actually good or just confident?
Confidence is free. Proof is not. Ask for three to five specific closed addresses from the last six months, a redacted pre-listing report, and two clients who closed in the last 90 days you can call. A good agent produces all three without hesitation. A sold sign in a yard proves a deal closed once, not that the agent was worth hiring.
Is the lowest commission the best deal when hiring an agent?
A fee is only high if the agent cannot recover it. Negotiation skill swings a final price by several percent, which dwarfs a fraction of a point on commission. The wrong agent who saves you a half-percent on fee can leave far more than that on the table at the closing table. Compare what each agent nets you, not what each agent charges you.
Should I let one agent represent both me and the other side?
One person cannot fight for the seller’s highest price and the buyer’s lowest price at the same time. The edge of real representation only works when your agent answers to you alone. A small fee saving is not worth handing away the one person whose job is to fight for your number. Keep an advocate on your side of the table.
How many homes should an agent have closed to be worth hiring?
Raw count matters less than recent, relevant production and a system you can inspect. An agent licensed 20 years who closed two deals last year is not the same as an agent closing steadily today. Ask for transactions in your price band over the last 12 months, the close rate behind them, and the process that produced them.
What questions expose an agent who is not tracking their results?
Ask for a close rate, a seller premium against comps, a concession-capture rate, and an average below-list savings figure. An agent who tracks performance answers with numbers and a source. An agent who answers “almost all of them” or “I get a good deal” is telling you the system is not measured, which means it is not repeatable.
Interview us first. Start with your home’s real value.
Request a Property Intelligence Report and you see how we work before any listing conversation. You get a data-backed valuation and the same numbers you would grill any agent on. Selling or buying, a real Artemis agent follows up, no hard close.
Or just call. We pick up.
618.685.0064Real people, seven days a week.
Equal Housing Opportunity. The Artemis Team at Real Broker, LLC is a licensed real estate brokerage in Illinois and Missouri. Information on this page is for general educational purposes, is believed accurate but not guaranteed, and is not legal, tax, or financial advice. Statistics reflect team performance over the stated period and are not a prediction of future results. Equal Housing Opportunity.